8 Swoony Baseball Romance Books That Hit It Out of the Park
These stories hit all the bases—and are sure to turn baseball season into the season of love!
From the crack of the bat to the roar of the crowd, there’s nothing quite like baseball season. And with spring training for Major League Baseball well underway, fans are eager to once again cheer on their favorite team (Go Yankees!). Whether you’re counting down the minutes until Opening Day on March 18 or looking for something to capture the spirit of America’s favorite pastime during the off-season, baseball romance books feel like a home run. These stories blend the thrill of the game with heartfelt love stories. Here, we gathered up our top eight baseball romance books that are sure to be a grand slam.
If you want a swoony romance between the coach’s daughter and the star pitcher, check out the Booktok sensation Caught Up by Liz Tomforde. Looking for a healing story about second chances at life instead? Dive into Evvie Drake Starts Over by Linda Holmes. Keep scrolling to catch all our baseball romance recommendations. Happy Reading!
‘The Bromance Book Club’ by Lyssa Kay Adams
Fans of rom-coms will flip for this fun, swoon-worthy tale! When second baseman for the Nashville Legends Gavin Scott finds out his wife, Thea, has been unhappy in their marriage and wants a divorce, he’s crushed. Desperate, Gavin finds help from an unlikely source: a secret romance book club made up of Nashville’s top alpha men. Will tips from the guys and steamy reads help Gavin win back the love of his life?
What readers are saying: “I’m obsessed with this book. It was swoony and romantic but also hilarious. It was such a perfect second-chance romance. I loved Thea and how she stood up for herself. I adored Gavin and his willingness to learn and grow to win Thea’s love. The Bromance boys were hilarious. The historical romance excerpts were a fun way to tie the book club with real life. I devoured every word of this one. If you love romance novels then there is no way you won’t enjoy this!
‘Caught Up’ by Liz Tomforde
Head to the Windy City and prepare to be swept off your feet with Caught Up, the third installment (that can be read as a standalone) in Liz Tomforde’s bestselling series. Kai Rhodes is the starting pitcher for Chicago’s MLB team, and he’s known for being one of the best. However, he’s also a single father struggling to balance his career with raising his son, Max. So far, Kai has gone through multiple nannies, none meeting his high standards. But when his coach steps in and appoints his daughter, Miller Montgomery, Kai has no choice but to accept.
Miller is an acclaimed pastry chef who just won a huge award, but she’s dealing with creative burnout. Excited for a change of pace, she quickly accepts her new role. Tensions rise quickly, and Kai and Miller aren’t off to the best start, but as they’re forced to spend more time together, their attraction and chemistry become undeniable.
What readers are saying: “Liz Tomforde can do no wrong. Baseball Dad Kai has my entire heart, and I loved this book. I was legit crying from cuteness; I couldn’t take it. Also, if it has the single dad trope, I’m definitely going to read it. Miller was also a powerhouse. Her baking was unmatched, and I adored the whole found family vibe she brought out in this book. I devoured this from start to finish, and it was a great way to continue this fantastic series.”
‘The Art of Catching Feelings’ by Alicia Thompson
Bestselling author Alicia Thompson pens another home run! In The Art of Catching Feelings, recently divorced Daphne Brink reluctantly attends a baseball game and then drunkenly heckles the handsome Carolina Battery player Chris Kepler. Oops! Full of regret, Daphne reaches out to Chris on social media to apologize…but he doesn’t realize who she is and they strike up a quick flirtation. Daphne decides to go with it, but how long can she lie about who she really is?
What readers are saying: “I adored this sweet and swoony sports romance! I love a book with humor and baseball! The Art of Catching Feelings was my first book by this author but it definitely won’t be the last! I’m completely hooked and can’t wait to read more of her books!!”
‘Stealing Home’ by Grace Reilly
A BookTok favorite, Grace Reilly’s third book in the Beyond the Play series is full of classic tropes, such as grumpy sunshine and forced proximity, and it’s sure to capture your heart. Set against the backdrop of college life and the pressures of upcoming professional careers, Stealing Home follows Mia, an aspiring astrophysicist, and Sebastian, a baseball player with dreams of landing big in the MLB. When the two end up being roommates for the summer, the chances of avoiding each other are slim to none, and before they know it, they find their feelings are much too strong to push down.
What readers are saying: “I fell in love with this series from the moment I started it, and I was SO excited for Stealing Home. I also had a feeling this book would be my favorite… and I was right. Aside from the romance, I enjoyed getting to know Mia and Sebastian individually. Their backstories and struggles had me tearing up for both of them, and I really liked the message of following your passions without sacrificing your happiness along the way.”
‘Fix Her Up’ by Tessa Bailey
Georgette Castle chose to plan kids’ parties over joining her family’s home renovation business—and no one has taken her seriously since. Travis Ford, Georgie’s brother’s best friend, is back in town following an injury that ruined his baseball career. With Georgie and Travis facing scrutiny, they plan to “fake date” to boost their reputations.
What readers are saying: “I adore Tessa Bailey! I am also a sucker for a good sports romance, and even though Travis didn’t really play anymore, I loved the baseball vibe. Georgie was a strong female character, and I enjoyed her development throughout the book. This was also delightfully spicy, and I was living for it!! This was super fun, and I couldn’t put it down!”
‘Evvie Drake Starts Over’ by Linda Holmes
This hilarious, hope-filled debut novel follows Evvie Drake, who rarely leaves her large, painfully empty house for nearly a year after losing her husband in a car crash. But when former baseball player Dean Tenney moves into the apartment at the back of Evvie’s house, the two make a deal: Dean won’t ask about Evvie’s late husband, and Evvie won’t ask about Dean’s failed career. But what follows is a sweet story of second chances.
What readers are saying: “This was such a beautiful and heart-warming story that gave me all the warm and fuzzies. When I finished, I was shedding happy tears and hugging my book. The main characters were fantastic. I absolutely adored Evvie. She was flawed, funny and relatable at times despite her situation. Her banter with Dean and her platonic best friend, Andy, was perfection. I’d highly recommend it if you love a feel-good, realistic book.”
‘Homerun Proposal’ by Maren Moore
When Hallie, a freshman at Orleans University, decides to ditch her nerdy image and put herself out there, she drafts a proposal for her best friend Eli to help her lose her virginity. However, thanks to a mix-up, the proposal lands in the hands of Lane Collins, Eli’s older brother and all-star baseball captain. Lane is cocky and has a playboy reputation, but he’s also been holding onto secret feelings for Hallie. Determined not to let his feelings get the best of him, Lane agrees to Hallie’s terms, offering to follow her checklist, stipulating that they part ways once it’s complete. But as they work through her list, the lines between real feelings and the proposal start to blur. Will they act on their connection or part ways when the checklist is finished?
What readers are saying: “I could talk about this book and its characters all day! The writing was phenomenal and the details in each scene made you feel like you were in the book itself. I 100 percent enjoyed this and couldn’t put it down. I highly recommend getting your own copy!!
‘You Should Be So Lucky’ by Cat Sebastian
Step back in time to 1960s baseball with this home run, the sequel to We Could Be So Good by Cat Sebastian. Eddie O’Leary is having the worst year of his career. He can’t hit the ball, he’s homesick, his teammates hate him and to top it all off, he’s living out of his suitcase. So when the team’s owner makes him do a bunch of interviews with a snobby reporter, he’s ready to call it quits. However, he’s already on thin ice, so he must put on a brave face and step up to the plate. Mark Bailey isn’t thrilled either, as he’s an arts reporter who doesn’t care about New York’s latest player. As Eddie and Mark are forced to spend more time together, their clashing personalities give way to mutual understanding and attraction.
What readers are saying: “This is, without hyperbole or exaggeration, one of the best romance novels that I’ve ever read. I cheered so hard for the characters’ happiness. I believed in their belonging to one another and wanted so desperately for them to believe it, too. I cried a lot, but I screamed joyfully even more. Please read it for yourself.”
Conversation
All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Woman's World does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.
