The Most Borrowed Audiobook Thrillers on Libby in 2026, Including 2 Freida McFadden Books
Forget expensive subscriptions—these five twisty, edge-of-your-seat audiobooks are free with your library card and impossible to pause!
Key Takeaways
- Libby is a free app that lets you borrow audiobooks with your library card.
- Five twisty thrillers, including two from Freida McFadden, make chores and walks fly by.
- Several picks feature multiple narrators, including ‘Local Woman Missing’ and ‘It’s Not Her.’
Who says a thrilling escape has to cost a fortune? If you haven’t tapped into Libby—the free app that connects straight to your local library card—you’re missing out on the best-kept secret in entertainment. Whether you’re tackling a mountain of laundry, taking your afternoon walk or winding down before bed, a great audiobook turns everyday chores into edge-of-your-seat me-time. And let’s be honest: There’s nothing quite like a talented narrator bringing every gasp, secret and plot twist straight to your earbuds.
Ready for your next listen? We talked to the people at Libby to find the most-borrowed psychological thrillers listeners devoured in 2026—including two unputdownable hits from queen of suspense Freida McFadden—where sharp intuition and hidden truths take center stage. Pop in your headphones, press play and prepare to lose track of time.
‘The Perfect Marriage’ by Jeneva Rose

On the surface, Washington, D.C. power attorney Sarah Morgan has it all—until her struggling-writer husband, Adam, is arrested for brutally stabbing his mistress to death at the couple’s secluded lake house. Rather than walking away from his betrayal, Sarah makes the jaw-dropping decision to take on the biggest case of her career: defending her own unfaithful husband in court. Packed with courtroom twists, marital mind games and shifting loyalties, this domestic thriller will have you questioning every motive until the final page.
Listen for: Dual-perspective narration that lets you hear both Sarah’s razor-sharp courtroom strategy and Adam’s panicked excuses—making every sudden shift in loyalty feel like you’re sitting right in the jury box.
What Goodreads readers are saying: “This is an extremely well written story with an intricate plot and skillfully drawn characters. it’s a real page turner roller coaster of a ride with twists and turns that seem to spin out of control. The ending was explosive and totally unexpected.”
‘Never Lie’ by Freida McFadden

Newlyweds Tricia and Ethan are house-hunting in the middle of nowhere when a fierce winter storm traps them inside a remote manor once owned by Dr. Adrienne Hale, a renowned psychiatrist who vanished without a trace years earlier. While snowed in and searching for shelter, Tricia stumbles upon a secret room containing audio cassette transcripts of every patient Dr. Hale ever treated. As Tricia presses play late into the night, she uncovers a chilling web of lies that proves nobody in the house is who they claim to be.
Listen for: Spine-tingling audio-within-an-audio production—hearing Dr. Hale’s eerie therapy sessions “play back” in your headphones makes you feel like you’re trapped inside that snowed-in manor right alongside Tricia.
What Goodreads readers are saying: “If you’re in the mood for a thrilling read that keeps you engaged from start to finish and delivers a jaw-dropping twist that you won’t see coming, this book should be on your must-read list.”
‘It’s Not Her’ by Mary Kubica

Courtney Gray is hoping for a peaceful, restorative family getaway at a quiet lakeside resort when a blood-curdling scream shatters the calm from the cottage next door. Rushing over to help, she discovers a horrific double murder—and realizes her own teenage niece has vanished from the scene. As investigators close in and long-buried family secrets come to light, Courtney must race to find her niece before suspicion destroys everyone she loves.
Listen for: Breathless, urgent pacing that ramps up the lakeside tension chapter by chapter, capturing every ounce of a family’s panic as the clock ticks down.
What Goodreads readers are saying: “Twisty, bingeable and addictive in the extreme, it was everything that I’ve come to expect from a Mary Kubica novel plus a little bit more. Let me tell you…those twists? Ms. Kubica really outdid herself this time around. But the best piece of this dynamite puzzle was the creepy, leave-the-lights-on feel that won me over one thousand percent.”
‘The Inmate’ by Freida McFadden

Desperate for a fresh start, nurse practitioner and single mom Brooke Sullivan takes a job at a men’s maximum-security prison where the rules are strict: treat prisoners with respect, share zero personal details and never get too friendly with the inmates. What the prison staff doesn’t know is that Brooke already has a history with one of the prisoners—her high school sweetheart, Shane, who is serving a life sentence for a series of grisly murders based largely on Brooke’s own eyewitness testimony. Now face-to-face behind bars, Brooke is forced to question whether she put the right man away—or if the real killer is still out there.
Listen for: Shifting timelines that seamlessly weave Brooke’s anxious present-day prison shifts with the haunting memories of her past, keeping you second-guessing every character’s motive until the final twist.
What Goodreads readers are saying: “This story captured my attention so much that I ended up reading it in a single day. From the first chapter of this book, all you want to know is how, why, and who? Freida has a way of making you think you have the whole story figured out and then she’ll throw the wildest plot twist your way.”
‘Local Woman Missing’ by Mary Kubica

In a quiet, tight-knit neighborhood, people don’t just vanish into thin air—until Shelby Tebow disappears, followed closely by local mom Meredith Dickey and her 6-year-old daughter, Delilah, just blocks away. With no solid leads, the cases go cold for 11 agonizing years—until Delilah suddenly reappears out of nowhere, battered and traumatized. As neighbors welcome her home, her return rips open old wounds and exposes the dark secrets residents have spent more than a decade trying to bury.
Listen for: Multiple distinct character voices that bring this tight-knit neighborhood to life—and make the chilling contrast between friendly small-talk and dark suburban secrets impossible to pause.
What Goodreads readers are saying: “You know that creepy feeling that you get when you walk alone through a parking garage late at night? That feeling where you have chills going up your spine? You just feel like something is going to happen? I felt like that this entire book! I loved, loved, loved the multiple POV’s and the timelines.”
Ready for more? Subscribe to our YouTube channel for video podcasts, health tips and uplifting stories designed for women 40, 50, 60 and beyond.
Conversation
All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Woman's World does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.