Already have an account?
Get back to the
Beauty

“I’m a 59-Year-Old Beauty Influencer and These Under-$20 Makeup Dupes Are My Secrets To Looking Younger Instantly”

Why spend more? With these dupes, you can save money and still look like a million bucks!

Whether you scroll through the beauty feeds of YouTube, TikTok or Instagram, you’re sure to find dozens of influencers singing the praises of “makeup dupes” — makeup products that are nearly identical to high-end formulas but cost a fraction of the price. But often, these dupes aren’t geared toward women over 50 and our top aging beauty concerns.

That’s why we tapped 59-year-old YouTuber Laura Rae (@LauraRaeBeauty) for her tried-and-true makeup dupes that cater to mature skin for a flawless and youthful appearance fast. Read on to discover the affordable products that will work wonders for you.

Makeup dupes benefit you and your wallet

“Makeup dupes are the secret to getting that luxurious look without breaking the bank,” says Rae. And, with the rising cost of makeup, it’s no wonder why dupes are becoming more and more popular among savvy shoppers. Rae explains while some folks define a dupe as an exact product match in color, texture and lasting power, others think that as long as the product achieves the same results once applied, it’s a dupe.

Often, high-end makeup products are pricier because of the fancy packaging they come in, but at the end of the day, what matters most is the quality of the product, not the box it comes in, she says. “So don’t be afraid to try out some affordable alternative to your favorite high-end products—your wallet will thank you and you’ll still look absolutely fabulous!”

Here, Rae’s top dupes that are sure to shed years from your appearance in an instant.

The best mascara makeup dupe to volumize lashes

A comparison between Benefit Roller Lash Curling Mascara and e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll Mascara; The e.l.f. product is a makeup dupe for the Benefit mascara
Benefit Cosmetics/e.l.f. Cosmetics/Canva

The splurge: Benefit Roller Lash Curling Mascara (Buy from Benefit, $28)

The dupe: e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll Mascara (Buy from e.l.f., $6)

Rae’s ultimate “beauty gamechanger”: A curling mascara, like e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll Mascara. “As we age, our eyelids tend to droop and make our eyes appear smaller, but longer, lifted lashes can give us an instantly more youthful look,” she says. (Click through to discover how drooping lids could contribute to a downward canthal tilt that can make you appear less attractive.)

For just $6, the e.l.f. mascara’s specially curved wand lifts and separates lashes for fullness and definition, and Rae says it works just as well as influencer-loved Benefit Roller Lash Curling Mascara. Bonus: Wiggle the mascara wand in a zig-zag motion starting at the base of lashes and move upward to ends. Repeat twice until lashes are fully coated and lifted.

The best lip gloss makeup dupe to make lips look fuller

A comparison of Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish and Maybelline Lifter Gloss; the Maybelline product is a makeup dupe for the Buxom lip gloss
Buxom/Maybelline/Canva

The splurge: Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish (Buy from Ulta, $25)

The dupe: Maybelline Lifter Gloss (Buy from Walmart, $6.98)

Swiping hyaluronic acid-infused Maybelline Lifter Gloss plumps up thin lips as effectively as the beloved Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish, which costs $16 more. How it helps: The acid, which is naturally found in skin and lips but is depleted with age, draws moisture deep into deflated lips, volumizing them fast for an instantly fuller look. Rae’s tip: “Apply it with a light hand, focusing on the center of your lips to avoid feathering into the lip line.”

The best foundation makeup dupe to brighten up dull skin

A comparison between MAC Studio Radiance Face and Body Sheer Foundation and Ulta Beauty Youthful Glow Foundation Serum Drops and talking about how they are makeup dupes for each other
MAC/Ulta/Canva

The splurge: MAC Studio Radiance Face and Body Sheer Foundation (Buy from MAC, $42)

The dupe: Ulta Beauty Youthful Glow Foundation Serum Drops (Buy from Ulta, $8)

A lightweight, water-based foundation, Ulta Beauty Youthful Glow Foundation Serum Drops even out skin’s tone and add a youthful, dewy glow to mature skin, notes Rae. That’s because the liquid formula won’t settle into fine lines and dry out or dull the complexion like a thick, matte foundation can. Even better? According to Rae, the drops have enough coverage to conceal dark circles and age spots, and the foundation blends into skin as seamlessly as MAC Studio Radiance Face and Body Sheer Foundation.

Check out the below video from Rae’s YouTube channel to see her test the two foundations side by side.

The best eyelid primer makeup dupe to make veins disappear

A comparison between MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow in Soft Ochre and Sormé Treatment Cosmetics Under Shadow Primer; the Sormé product is a makeup dupe for the MAC product
MAC/Sormé/Canva

The splurge: MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow in Soft Ochre (Buy from Nordstrom, $25)

The dupe: Sormé Treatment Cosmetics Under Shadow Primer (Buy from Sormé, $14)

A flexible, non-flaking eyeshadow primer in a neutral shade, Sormé Treatment Cosmetics Under Shadow Primer creates a uniform base that fully covers imperfections on eyelid skin that’s become thinner from a natural loss of collagen as we older. And it works just as well as beloved MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow in Soft Ochre at covering discoloration and creating a base for eyeshadow so it stays put and looks smoother, notes Rae — and for $11 less! Tip: Tap and blend the product onto eyelids with an eyeshadow brush and let sit for 1 minute before applying eyeshadow on top. (Click through to discover more anti-aging eye makeup.)

Check out the below video from Rae’s YouTube channel to see how she uses the Sormé product for more than just her eyelids.

The best eyebrow pencil makeup dupe to thicken brows

A comparison between Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz and NYX Micro Brow Pencil; the NYX product is a makeup dupe for the Anastasia Beverly Hills eyebrow pencil
Anastasia Beveryly Hills/NYX, Canva

The splurge: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz (Buy From Anastasia, $25)

The dupe: NYX Micro Brow Pencil (Buy from NYX, $11)

Rae’s key to fabulous, fuller-looking brows is to use NYX Micro Brow Pencil, an ultra fine–tipped pencil that fills in sparse spots for just $11. That’s a steal since the pencil works just as effortlessly as its pricier $25 counterpart: the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz. For a flawless finish, Rae suggests using the pencil in gentle, hair-like strokes to create a brow that looks natural, not filled in. (Click through to learn more tricks to disguise and repair sparse eyebrows.)

The best eye brightener makeup dupe to erase dark circles

A comparison between Smashbox Becca Under Eye Brightening Corrector and Catrice Cosmetics Under Eye Brightener; the Catrice Cosmetics product is a makeup dupe for the Smashbox eye brightener
Smashbox/Catrice Cosmetics/Canva

The splurge: Smashbox Becca Under Eye Brightening Corrector (Buy from Smashbox, $33)

The dupe: Catrice Cosmetics Under Eye Brightener (Buy from Catrice Cosmetics, $6)

The peach tint of Catrice Cosmetics Under Eye Brightener instantly cancels out the blue undertones of dark under-eye circles, giving eyes a brighter, more wide-awake look. “It’s my favorite replacement for Smashbox Becca Under Eye Brightening Corrector and it works even better on mature skin,” says Rae. That’s because the dupe contains castor oil that draws moisture into skin to “plump up” sunken-in circles. And the oil’s compounds boost circulation to prevent blood from pooling underneath the eyes and creating dark circles in the first place. Plus, adds Rae, its creamy, lightweight formula won’t emphasize under-eye creases like the thicker Smashbox product can.

The best lipstick makeup dupe to smooth out lip lines

A comparison of Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick and Treslúce Beauty Empower Me Matte Lipstick in Nudey Pink; the Treslúce product is a makeup dupe for the Charlotte Tilbury lipstick
Charlotte Tilbury/Treslúce/Canva

The splurge: Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick (Buy from Charlotte Tilbury, $35)

The dupe: Treslúce Beauty Empower Me Matte Lipstick in Nudey Pink (Buy on Treslúce, $16)

Matte lipstick has a reputation for causing dry, wrinkled lips to look even more shriveled, but fortunately Rae assures that’s not the case with Treslúce Beauty Empower Me Matte Lipstick in Nudey Pink. The pinky nude-hued formula is infused with fatty acid-rich mango butter that deeply hydrates lips and “fills in” lip lines. What’s more, vitamin C in the lipstick promotes collagen production so lip skin stays looking smooth and supple. Rae notes that the matte lipstick is a fantastic dupe for cult favorite Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick and costs less than half the price. (Click through to discover more anti-aging lipsticks.)


Click through for more affordable beauty finds:

Best Makeup Dupes of Summer 2023: Six Affordable Product Swaps for Gorgeous Hair, and Skin

These Are the 8 Best Hacks for Saving Money on Beauty Products and Toiletries

Dolly Parton Reveals the Drugstore Makeup She’s Relied on For Years — And It’s All Under $10

Woman’s World aims to feature only the best products and services. We update when possible, but deals expire and prices can change. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission. Questions? Reach us at shop@womansworld.com.


Use left and right arrow keys to navigate between menu items. Use right arrow key to move into submenus. Use escape to exit the menu. Use up and down arrow keys to explore. Use left arrow key to move back to the parent list.