Best Audiobooks to Listen to This September, According to Spotify Editors
From historical fiction to romance, this list has something for every listener
Key Takeaways
- Spotify editors have selected these five audiobooks for September listening.
- The picks span romance, historical fiction, horror, family drama and mystery.
- From spooky-season scares to cozy small-town stories, there’s a fall listen for every mood.
Fall is in full swing, and if you’re looking for something new to listen to, Spotify has you covered. Their editors have released their favorite books on audio to listen to this September, and trust us when we say they’re worth clearing your queue for. To see our top five audiobook picks from Spotify’s editors’ recommended listening for September, keep scrolling!
‘Soul Searching’ by Lyla Sage
This #1 New York Times bestseller, which is narrated by Jason Clarke and Samantha Brentmoor, begins when Collins Cartwright returns to her hometown of Sweetwater Peak, Wyoming, jobless and out of money. Even worse is the fact that the ghosts that have always kept her company have gone silent. Brady Cooper is new in town, and after he lets Collins stay in his guest room, sparks begin to fly between them. A spicy tale that is perfect for spooky season.
What listeners are saying: “This was my first Lyla Sage book and I love that I did audio because I feel like the narrators did a fantastic job capturing the characters. The banter was top tier and it was just a solid comfy read.”
‘Amity’ by Nathan Harris
Set in 1866 New Orleans, this novel, which is narrated by André Santana and Angel Pean, follows siblings Coleman and June, two former slaves who are struggling to find the peace they were promised. Two years ago, the siblings were separated when their master, Mr. Harper, took June to Mexico to try and escape the crumbling South, and Coleman stayed behind in Louisiana. Then, one day, a letter arrives summoning Coleman to Mexico and he thinks that he’s finally going to get reunited with his sister, but when a tragedy strikes, Coleman is forced to go on the run with Florence, his master’s daughter. What follows is a battle of bravery, strength, friendship and family.
What listeners are saying: “One more brilliant book by Nathan Harris and I will dub him my favorite author. I absolutely loved this book. Great story filled with adventure, history and love. The narrators were perfect.”
‘Play Nice’ by Rachel Harrison
Narrated by Alex Finke and Natasha Soudek, this gripping tale follows Clio Louise Barnes, who spent her childhood in a haunted house. When her parents split, Clio’s mother Alex relocated her and her sisters to a home she insisted was possessed by a demon. Years later, after Alex is discovered dead, Clio returns to the property to film a renovation, only to realize her mother’s ghost stories may have been real all along.
What listeners are saying: “I absolutely devoured the audiobook of Play Nice by Rachel Harrison. As someone who reads a ton of paranormal horror and often finds them predictable, this one was a thrilling surprise. The haunted-house vibes, influencer culture twist, and sibling tension all came together in a way that kept me genuinely on edge and invested. If you’re craving horror that still knows how to scare and surprise, this is it.”
‘Buckeye’ by Patrick Ryan
Narrated by Michael Crouch, this Read With Jenna pick transports readers to a small Ohio town in the aftermath of World War II. When Cal Jenkins and Margaret Salt’s affair is exposed, their lives become forever entangled, even though Cal is married to Becky and Margaret is married to Felix. Decades later, secrets begin to come to light, threatening to destroy both families. A compelling exploration of family, love and the consequences of one’s actions.
What listeners are saying: “This book was one that I just didn’t want to end. I loved the characters, the storyline, the descriptions, the narrator, everything! What a beautiful story.”
‘Murderous Business’ by Cathy Pegau
If you love queer historical fiction, you won’t want to miss this novel, which is narrated by Quinn Riley. After her father dies, Margot Baxter Harriman takes the reins of B&H Foods, but it’s hard to be a woman in charge in 1912. To make matters worse, Mrs. Gilroy, her father’s former assistant, is found dead in the office with a note that claims B&H Foods has engaged in illegal activity. Loretta “Rett” Mancini has run her father’s investigation company for years, and when she hears about a potential case at B&H, she jumps on it. As Margot and Rett’s lives collide, feelings and secrets emerge.
What listeners are saying: “A compelling glimpse into how awful women were treated. Glad my favorite librarian in Cordova recommended this book.”
Conversation
All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Woman's World does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.
