While I inevitably lament the transition from warm to cold weather every year, one thing that lifts my spirits (aside from the promise of cider doughnuts and Halloween candy!) is the thought of wrapping myself in a plush, snuggly blanket once temperatures start to dip. And, since my allergies tend to flare up with the change in seasons, I’ll be reaching for one of the best down alternative comforters to keep my sniffles at bay and warm me up on chilly evenings. Actually, just the thought of swaddling myself in a fluffy blanket with my Netflix queue geared up is almost enough to make those bittersweet seasonal feelings fade away!
If you’re ready to embrace the cooler months and want to turn your bed into a cozy haven, keep reading to learn more about the best down alternative comforters — and see why you might want to opt for one over a traditional down blanket this season!
What is the best down alternative comforter?
- Best down alternative comforter for hot sleepers : The Buffy Breeze
- Best warm down alternative comforter : Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter
- Best down alternative comforter set : KASENTEX All Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter Set
- Bestselling down alternative comforter on Amazon : Utopia Bedding Down Alternative Comforter
- Best reversible down alternative comforter : SUPERIOR Down Alternative Comforter
- Best down alternative comforter for menopause : Avocado Alpaca Duvet Insert
- Best lightweight down alternative comforter : Parachute Down Alternative Duvet Insert
- Best all-season down alternative comforter : Snowe Down Alternative Comforter
- Best cotton down alternative comforter : Coyuchi Diamond-Stitched Organic Cotton Comforter
- Best hypoallergenic down alternative comforter : PlushBeds Handmade Natural Wool Comforter
What is the difference between a down comforter and a down alternative comforter?
Before we start talking about the best down alternative comforters on the market, we should discuss the difference between down and down alternatives. While many people think “down” simply refers to bird feathers, it’s actually the fluffy undercoating of the feathers, particularly those of waterfowl, like ducks, geese, and swans. Unlike feathers, down doesn’t have a quill, and since it acts as an insulator for birds, it’s become wildly popular as a filling for things like bedding and the best winter coats.
While there’s no denying down can add a great deal of warmth without feeling too heavy, there are benefits to using down alternatives. Here are some of the more common materials used in place of down:
- Wool: An animal fiber most commonly derived from (but not limited to) sheep, wool is natural, breathable, moisture-wicking, and temperature-regulating, making it a great material for year-round use.
- Microfiber: Made of synthetic materials (like polyester and nylon), microfiber is made up of super-fine fibers, so it’s very soft and breathable. It’s often more affordable than natural materials, though products made with microfibers can contribute to plastic pollution, especially via laundry, so it’s wise to consider alternative laundering methods to lessen their impact.
- Bamboo: Bamboo bedding products are becoming more and more popular, thanks to their breathability, soft and gentle textures, and the fact that they’re hypoallergenic. One thing to keep in mind, however, is that they can be prone to shrinking, so you may want to consider air-drying bamboo blankets and sheets to help preserve their shape and size.
- Cotton: Among the most popular materials for bedding, clothing, and practically anything made from fabric, cotton is another natural down alternative known for its durability, softness, and for being low-maintenance and easy to care for. You’ll want to check to see if your bedding is made from 100 percent cotton or a cotton blend, as they have different properties: A cotton blend won’t wrinkle as much, for instance, while 100 percent cotton is usually softer and more breathable.
So, why choose one of the best down alternative comforters over one made with down? For starters, they’re a great option for people who suffer from allergies. According to Dr. Morris Nejat, a physician and Chief Medical Officer of NY Allergy & Sinus Centers, “Fillers such as down can cause allergy symptoms in predisposed individuals. Down can provide a fertile home for the growth of dust mites, which can also cause allergies, as well as animal and roach particles. Natural and synthetic down alternatives are more hypoallergenic and can make it harder for the presence of other indoor allergens.”
Another benefit of many down alternative comforters is that they’re vegan-friendly and cruelty-free. Aside from wool, most down alternatives are derived from plants or made with synthetic materials, and many brands will specify if their products are cruelty-free for extra assurance. Down, while warm, has been linked to controversial and unethical sourcing practices, so purchasing down alternative bedding can provide peace of mind.
Lastly, because of the labor intensive nature of sourcing down, products made with this insulator can be very expensive. That said, if you’re on a budget, choosing one of the best down alternative comforters can be a great way to save money while still getting top-notch comfort!
What is the best type of comforter?
In my opinion, bedding is one of the most polarizing subjects out there — just ask anyone who has ever had to share a bed with someone else! With that in mind, the best down alternative comforters come in many styles, materials, and densities, to name a few. Before choosing the best fit for you, you’ll want to consider a few things.
First and foremost, are you a “hot sleeper” or a “cold sleeper”? While I’m someone who gets cold from even the slightest breeze in the air, I’m actually among the many people who identify as hot sleepers, meaning I prefer a more lightweight, breathable comforter to keep me from getting too sweaty and sticky at night. Cold sleepers, on the other hand, usually opt for a thicker comforter to prevent them from shivering under the covers — we want to avoid either of these extremes!
Luckily, many of the best down alternative comforters on our list come in both lightweight and what is referred to as “all-season” densities, so you’ll definitely have options to choose from. All-season comforters are designed to be just a bit heavier than their lightweight counterparts, and aim to strike that perfect sweet spot that makes them ideal for year-round usage — they’re a great, versatile investment!
In addition to the thickness of your comforter, the material it’s made from can have a huge impact on your comfort level as well. For instance, natural materials, like wool, alpaca fiber, and eucalyptus are inherently hypoallergenic, meaning they’ll help ward off sneezes and sniffles if you suffer from allergies. They also have temperature-regulating properties, meaning they’ll adapt to help you stay comfortable — really! As your body heats up, these materials will transfer the heat away from you, and when it’s colder, they’ll retain heat to keep you warm. They’re also moisture-wicking, so they’ll draw sweat away from your body to keep you nice and dry — you really can’t go wrong!
While comforters made from these natural materials are fantastic, they can be on the pricier side, so if you’re on a budget, look for the best down alternative comforters made with synthetic materials, like microfiber. While they won’t have quite the same luxurious feel as natural materials, there are still great options out there to give your old covers a run for their money!
Are down alternative comforters safe?
The last thing anyone wants to worry about when going to sleep is how their bedding could affect their health. Luckily, there are things you can look for while shopping for the best down alternative comforters to put your mind at ease.
First, check to see if the brand lists any certifications, such as OEKO-TEX certifications, which ensure a lack of harmful chemicals, and GOTS certifications, which note that certain ecological and social standards for organic materials are met. To prevent allergy symptoms and discomfort, you can also check to see if the materials being used are hypoallergenic — which many down alternatives are.
As far as what to steer clear of, Dr. Nejat says to “avoid chemicals, which have their own issues,” along with “anything with a chemical smell.” And, if considering a comforter made with microfiber, keep in mind that, while some are hypoallergenic, they can cause irritation if you have sensitive skin, so you might want to opt for one made with natural materials if that’s a potential issue.
Want to make your bed the coziest ever? Check out our picks for the best mattresses for adjustable beds, the best mattress toppers for back pain and hip pain, and the best adjustable beds for seniors to pair with the best down alternative comforters on our list. Bring it on, winter!
Keep scrolling to read about the best down alternative comforters of 2021! (Note that all prices listed are for Queen-sized comforters, and other sizes will vary).
See more of our best product recommendations.
We write about products we think our readers will like. If you buy them, we get a small share of the revenue from the supplier.
15 Best Down Alternative Comforters 2021
Why we like it:
- Made of 100% eucalyptus
- Cool-to-the-touch material
If you’re one of the many people who tend to “sleep hot,” you’re probably all too familiar with the toss- and turn-inducing effects of bedding that’s too warm. Throw menopause and night sweats into the mix, and getting a good night’s sleep might seem near impossible! Luckily, some blankets are actually designed with you in mind, and the Buffy Breeze is our pick for the best down alternative comforter with cooling properties. What sets this comforter apart from the rest? For starters, it’s made from 100 percent eucalyptus fibers (both shell and filling), which are naturally temperature-regulating, cool to the touch, and breathable. I personally love the modern wave pattern, which helps elevate the clean white fabric and ensures the filling remains evenly distributed throughout. Plus, this comforter is cruelty-free and OEKO-TEX-certified, meaning you won’t have to worry about breathing in any harmful substances.
One Buffy shopper, who “suffers from hot flashes during the night,” called the Breeze “perfect,” saying, “[It’s] very well made with a luxurious feel!” Another wrote, “I love this because I sleep so hot, but I also want the weight of covers on me,” and said, “[It] provides the cozy cocoon that gives me comfort when I want to cuddle up. It’s pretty perfect.”
Why we like it:
- Ultra-warm option provides extra coziness
- Also comes in lightweight and all-season densities
If you live somewhere that feels downright frigid come winter (or tend to sleep cold), you’ll want to invest in a blanket you can get nice and toasty under. Enter: The Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter, which comes in lightweight, all-season, and ultra-warm options. When it comes to turning your bedroom into a cozy winter retreat, the ultra-warm is the way to go, thanks to its extra heft. Designed to emulate down’s billowy feel, the microfiber filling is contained within the large baffle box design to preserve its loft, and the super soft, 100 percent cotton sateen shell feels like a dream. Whether you’re curling up with a good book or movie in front of the fire, having a snow day snuggle session, or simply turning in for a deep sleep, this is one comforter you’ll want to stay wrapped up in all winter long!
One satisfied customer said, “I live in Michigan, and this comforter is warm.” She went on to say, “It will be great this fall and winter,” thanks to the fact that it’s “great quality” and “very cozy!“
Why we like it:
- Available in 8 color options
- Set includes comforter and 2 shams
- Over 8,000 5-star ratings on Amazon
If you truly want to get some bang for your buck, this down alternative comforter set includes two matching shams — all for under $60! Choose from one of eight lovely color schemes, all of which feature two-toned, reversible designs, so it’s really like you’re getting multiple quilts in one. The lofty down alternative filling contains foam for a delightfully ‘floaty’ feel, and the all-season weight makes this the perfect comforter for year-round use. Plus, it’s moisture-resistant to keep you sweat-free throughout the night.
One Amazon reviewer wrote, “This is literally the softest, most comfortable blanket I’ve EVER had in all my 44 years.” They added, “I cannot describe how this blanket feels when I climb into bed,” and said, “I spent a little over 200 dollars once for a comforter and it was NOWHERE near as luxurious. It feels like one of those comforters in a 5+ star luxury resort or hotel.”
Why we like it:
- Under $30!
- Comes in 4 neutrals
- Over 42,000 5-star ratings on Amazon
It’s not surprising this bestselling comforter on Amazon has so many fans (and over 42,000 five-star ratings!). After all, it’s cushy enough to rival many top brands, but at a fraction of the cost — this one clocks in at under $30! Made with 100 percent microfiber, this comfy blanket is soft to the touch, while the box stitching helps keep the plush, all-season filling in place (and looks stylish, to boot!). We also love that it comes in white, gray, black, or navy to suit any bedroom, and the fact that it can be tossed into the washer and dryer when it’s time for a refresh!
One surprised reviewer “expected a cheap, thin duvet,” but was impressed by the fact that this one turned out to be “super soft and extremely comfortable.” She even said it was “easily comparable” to one that she’d paid $250 for, and that she’ll be “ordering for the whole family!”
Why we like it:
- Available in 3 great colors, as well as black, gray, and white
- Reversible design
- Can be used on its own or as a duvet insert
What makes this comfy down alternative comforter by SUPERIOR so great? First off, it comes in three vibrant colors (I’m partial to the pictured dusty orange), as well as white, black, or gray, and its reversible design means you’ll get more use out of it before having to freshen it up. That said, cleaning this comforter is a breeze (it’s washer- and dryer-friendly!), and the baffle-box construction ensures the filling remains evenly distributed. Plus, it can be used on your bed as is, or as a duvet insert — either way, you’ll be snoozing in style!
Over 3,500 Amazon reviewers gave this comforter a five-star rating, and one wrote, “This is the softest, warmest, and somehow also coolest duvet I have ever had.” They went on to say, “It’s fluffy and luxurious, while also breathable. I love sleeping with it — it feels like being covered by a cloud.”
Why we like it:
- Made with 100% organic cotton and natural alpaca fiber
- Comes in lightweight or all-season
Hot flashes, night sweats — ah, the joys of menopause! While it’s common for many of us to experience these symptoms, there are steps we can take to avoid discomfort while we try to sleep, and finding the right bedding is one of them. Our pick for the best down alternative comforter for menopause is this lusciously soft duvet insert by Avocado Mattress, which is filled with natural alpaca fiber to keep you from overheating at night. Not only is alpaca wool naturally temperature-regulating, it’s also moisture-wicking (sweat, be gone!), breathable, lightweight, and hypoallergenic — essentially, it’s a wonder material! The alpaca fiber fill is encased in a 100 percent GOTS-certified organic cotton percale case, which offers supreme softness and aligns with Avocado’s dedication to sustainability. Choose from lightweight or all-season options depending on how thick you like your comforters to be, and if you’d like a duvet cover to pair with your luxurious new blanket, Avocado offers organic linen and organic cotton options.
One reviewer, who purchased the lightweight comforter, said, “It’s perfect,” and appreciates the “great air circulation.” She went on to say, “I have no A/C and it was fine even when the summer got a little warm here in Seattle.”
Why we like it:
- Filled with 100% hypoallergenic microfiber
- Baffle box construction keeps filling evenly distributed
- 5-year warranty
Parachute is known for its soft and dreamy bedding, and this down alternative duvet insert is no exception. While it comes in both lightweight and all-season densities, we recommend the lightweight option for hot sleepers and those who live in warmer climates. Filled with 100 percent hypoallergenic microfiber, this blanket mimics the luxurious comfort of down, but without the stuffiness (or sniffles!) that often accompany it. A soft sateen shell features large baffle box construction for an invitingly fluffy aesthetic and to prevent the filling from clumping, with double-stitched seams for extra reinforcement. Simply toss it into the washer and dryer for effortless cleaning, and take comfort in the fact that it comes with a five-year warranty. And if you’re looking for a duvet cover to pair with your new comforter, Parachute has a number of gorgeous options to choose from.
One happy buyer wrote, “I did not know I could be this obsessed with a duvet insert,” and said it “feels like a cloud is floating over you while you sleep.” She added, “We have ours tucked inside the Parachute linen duvet cover and it is truly a perfect match. I highly recommend this for anyone looking to upgrade their bedding!“
Why we like it:
- All-season comforter has 40% more fill than the lightweight option
- Filled with 100% allergen-free microfiber
- Washer- and dryer-friendly
These days, many of the best down alternative comforters come in what’s called an “All-Season” density, meaning, they’re designed to fit that not-too-hot, not-too-cold sweet spot for year-round use. The down alternative comforter by Snowe comes in both all-season and lightweight feels, but if you tend to sleep a bit cooler, the all-season is the one for you. Made with 40 percent more fill than the lightweight model, this comfy blanket offers a bit of extra weight to keep you nice and warm during the winter, though the cotton sateen cover ensures it won’t stifle you during the hot months. Have allergies? The 100 percent allergen-free, microfiber filling will keep sniffles at bay, so you can sleep undisturbed. And should it need a cleaning, simply throw it into the washer and dryer!
One reviewer, who said she and her husband had “not been sleeping well” and were “sweating throughout the nights” with their down comforter, called this down alternative comforter a “GAME CHANGER,” saying they’re now “back to great sleep!”
Why we like it:
- Made of 100% organic cotton
- Diamond-shaped quilting holds batting in place
- Machine washable
If you’re looking for bedding that’s cozy, but also extremely low maintenance, a cotton comforter is a great bet. We love this Coyuchi comforter, which is made with 100 percent organic cotton batting and a soft, crinkled percale shell that’s just begging to be curled up with on a lazy day. There’s an appealing, carefree vibe to the relaxed draping, though the diamond-shaped quilting also makes this blanket look chic and sophisticated — in addition to keeping the fill nice and evenly distributed. Keep in mind that it’s just a tad on the thin side for winter, but it’s perfect for the warmer months (and people who sleep hot!). Oh, and back to low maintenance — like all of Coyuchi’s organic cotton bedding, this comforter is washer- and dryer-friendly!
One fan called this comforter “luxurious,” saying, “It adds to the look of our bed” and “isn’t bulky, but is really warm and cozy.”
Why we like it:
- Mildew-resistant and moisture-wicking
- Filled with 100% virgin ECOWOOL
- Dense, yet lightweight
Let’s face it: It’s pretty tough to get a good night’s sleep when the sneezing fits ensue! As someone with seasonal, mold, and dust allergies, I have firsthand experience with this frustrating scenario, but it’s comforting to know that the right bedding can make all the difference. Take this hypoallergenic, natural wool comforter by PlushBeds, for instance. It’s made with 100 percent pure, virgin wool, so you won’t have to worry about breathing in any harsh chemicals. Wool is also naturally hypoallergenic and mildew-resistant to help you sleep more peacefully (i.e. sneeze-free!), so you can wake up in the morning feeling nice and refreshed. Aside from being a great option for allergy-sufferers, this comforter is also ideal for hot sleepers, as it wicks away moisture (so long, sweaty sheets!) and has a breathable, organic cotton cover. It’s also surprisingly lightweight, given how dense wool can be, and is temperature-regulating to keep you feeling comfortable all year long.
One satisfied customer said this comforter is “worth every cent,” and called it “the most beautiful blanket I’ve ever seen.” She went on to say that it’s “amazingly soft” and that she “might not ever get out of bed!”
Why we like it:
- 100% cotton sateen shell
- Glass microbeads provide a cozy, weighted feel
- Baffle box construction ensures even weight distribution
Not everyone prefers a lightweight comforter, especially when the evenings get chillier. If that sounds like you, Brooklinen’s Weighted Comforter might be just the thing to keep you feeling nice and snug on a cold winter’s night. Filled with glass microbeads, which provide that secure, weighted feeling, this comforter features a baffle box construction that evenly distributes the filling (no clumps!). This results in a calming pressure applied all over the body to help you get a deep night’s sleep — just thinking about it makes me want to drift off! The queen-sized comforter weighs 20 pounds (!), so you might get a bit of a workout in while making the bed, but just think of how peaceful you’ll sleep once it’s on. On a more convenient note, the corners are fitted with loops to attach to the duvet cover of your choice, and Brooklinen offers several options to have your bed looking and feeling its best.
One Brooklinen shopper, who has restless leg syndrome and fibromyalgia, called this comforter “an absolute miracle product,” and said it’s the “best thing I’ve ever had in my bed.” She went on to say, “I highly, highly recommend if you have any issues with sleeping, have body aches, [or] trouble with relaxing.”
Why we like it:
- Filled with 100% climate beneficial wool
- Non-allergenic and dust mite-proof
- Slightly weighted feeling
Wool sometimes gets a bad rap for being itchy or abrasive, but with a wool comforter, you can reap all the benefits of this underrated material without any discomfort. In fact, this wool duvet insert by Coyuchi will make your bed feel like a plush retreat, thanks to its slightly weighted feeling and cozy warmth. This particular comforter is filled with 100 percent climate beneficial wool, meaning it’s better for the earth, and has a 100 percent organic cotton cover for a super-soft feel. Since wool is denser than down, despite being thinner, there is a bit of heft to this blanket, which is great for people who love a heavier, “body-hugging” feeling while they sleep. That said, wool — in addition to being non-allergenic and dust mite-proof — is also temperature-regulating, so it’ll help you maintain a comfortable temperature, no matter what time of year it is. To complement your blanket, Coyuchi also offers a wide range of duvet covers, so you can sleep in style.
According to one happy reviewer, who was “suffering [from] night sweats and overheating” with her down blanket, this one “definitely regulates heat better and isn’t clingy like the down.” She also said it’s kept her “warm on the cool nights and cool on the warm nights,” and that she was “worried about spending this much on a blanket” but “it’s worth it!”
Why we like it:
- Made of premium 100% viscose from bamboo
- Super soft and lightweight
If Cozy Earth’s bamboo bedding is good enough for Oprah, it’s good enough for me! As someone with dry, sensitive skin, I find the feel of ultra-smooth fabrics so refreshing, which is why this oh-so-soft bamboo comforter had to have a place on the list. Made with premium 100 percent viscose from bamboo, which is also OEKO-TEX-certified (no nasty chemicals!), this dreamy comforter is billed as having “the world’s softest feel” — and if Oprah says it’s true, I believe her! It’s ideal for hot sleepers and those living in humid climates, thanks to its lightweight feel and temperature-regulating and moisture-wicking properties — in fact, Cozy Earth even says you’ll sleep up to three degrees cooler with this comforter! For superior luxury, pair with Cozy Earth’s bamboo duvet cover and feel like you’re sleeping in a bed fit for a queen — or, Oprah!
According to one Cozy Earth shopper, “The investment is worth every penny,” as “we spend a lot of time sleeping and we should all sleep the best we can!” They went on to say, “These are by far the most amazing sheets and quilt I have ever owned. I no longer run hot at night and climbing into bed is something I look forward to.”
Why we like it:
- Extra-fluffy recycled fill
- Dust- and mold-resistant
If you’re anything like me, there’s nothing quite like the feel of wrapping yourself in a fluffy blanket after a long day. Luckily, the Buffy Cloud was designed with people like us in mind, thanks to an ultra-soft eucalyptus shell and a 100 percent recycled PET, BPA-free fill that feels like a billowy marshmallow. And not only does this blanket offer physical comfort, it’s also great for peace of mind: Each comforter makes use of approximately 50 recycled plastic bottles (hello, eco-consciousness!) and it’s cruelty-free. The “earth-friendly” eucalyptus fiber also doesn’t contain essential oils, making it safe for pets and kids — and since it’s both dust- and mold-resistant, you’ll be spared the nighttime sniffles!
One Buffy customer called this comforter “super comfortable,” and said, “The material is light and airy and sooo soft!” She went on to say, “I’m a warm sleeper and this comforter kept me cozy all night without overheating. Love it!”
Why we like it:
- Under $50!
- Over 9,000 5-star ratings on Wayfair
- Ideal for year-round use
While we believe good bedding is worth splurging on, a quality comforter doesn’t have to be super expensive — and this affordable quilt by The Twillery Co. has over 9,000 five-star ratings on Wayfair to prove it! It costs less than $50, but you’d never know it, thanks to its elegant piped trim and plush, box-stitch construction. It’s designed for all-season use, giving you even more bang for your buck, and the fact that it’s washing machine-friendly helps seal the deal. It just goes to show you don’t have to spend a lot to have your bed feel like a million bucks!
One of this comforter’s many happy buyers said, “The quality is great for the price point,” and “I feel enveloped, cozy, and soft… which is the whole point!” Another called it “super fluffy,” saying, “It’s like a cloud inside,” and that it’s “not too hot, just right and light!”