Naproxen vs. Ibuprofen: A Doctor Reveals Which Works Faster and Eases Pain Longer
Plus see the potential side effect women over 50 need to know
Whether you strained a muscle playing a meaner-than-you-meant game of pickleball or are nursing the chronic pain of arthritis, the last thing you want to do when you’re achy is second-guess which over-the-counter medicine is best for you. So if you’re debating two of the most common nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)—naproxen (Aleve) vs. ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin)—look no further. We asked a top doctor to explain the key differences between these medications, how to choose between them and when it may be better to consider alternative pain relievers.
The difference between naproxen and ibuprofen
To better understand how these over-the-counter pain relievers work, picture a running track. “Ibuprofen, commonly known as Advil or Motrin, is kind of like the sprinter, the medication that gets immediate control of your pain,” reveals Anita Gupta, DO, PharmD, MPP, FASA, adjunct assistant professor of anesthesiology and pain medicine at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.
“While ibuprofen is great for the flash-in-the-pan kind of pain, like a sudden headache or fever, you do have to keep ‘chasing it’ every four to six hours,” she continues.
Woman's World Answers
Naproxen, in contrast, is more like the marathoner that works long-term. “It takes a bit longer to kick in, but it’s a steady workhorse that stays in your system for at least 12 hours,” says Dr. Gupta. “It’s better for chronic stiffness or pain that isn’t going away by lunchtime.”
Bottom line? The key difference between these meds is their duration. “If you twist your ankle, for example, ibuprofen is your best friend for immediate relief from sharp pain and swelling,” adds Dr. Gupta. “But if you have osteoarthritis and wake up with stiff joints, reach for naproxen—it’s superior, because you’ll only need two pills a day to stay ahead of the inflammation.”
What women over 50 need to know about NSAIDs
Dr. Gupta highlights a common pitfall: “For the many women taking baby aspirin to prevent heart attacks or strokes, it’s important to know that ibuprofen can negate those benefits.”
“It’s sort of a biological traffic jam,” she explains. “Aspirin works by attaching to your platelets to prevent clots and ibuprofen targets that exact same spot. If the ibuprofen gets there first, it can block the aspirin from latching on, which can strip away the heart-protective benefits you’re looking for.”
She adds that if you’re taking baby aspirin—or aspirin with ibuprofen—you should talk to your doctor about taking them together, because they may interact and affect your heart health.
Naproxen vs. ibuprofen: A key safety concern to consider
Like so much in medicine, there’s an important trade-off to consider when choosing between these medications, and it involves the heart vs. the gut, reveals Dr. Gupta. Let’s address cardiovascular health first: “Studies suggest that naproxen may be slightly, just slightly, safer for the heart.”
That’s why, depending on a patient’s history and risk of cardiovascular events, physicians will sometimes lean a little more toward naproxen—but always under a doctor’s supervision, she emphasizes.
Now for the gastrointestinal side of the equation: “All NSAIDs can irritate the stomach, and because naproxen stays in the system longer, it has a longer window to potentially affect the gut,” Dr. Gupta explains. That’s the trade-off: A small advantage for the heart may come with a slightly higher risk of gastrointestinal issues.
Thankfully, the best way to avoid stomach upset when taking these medications is simple. “The golden rule with NSAIDs that we tell every patient is: Don’t take anything on an empty stomach,” advises Dr. Gupta.
Are NSAIDs right for you?
It’s also worth noting that any NSAID can nudge your blood pressure higher. As Dr. Gupta puts it, these drugs affect the kidneys’ ability to balance sodium and water, which essentially “bumps up your blood pressure levels.”
Of course, this is especially important if you already have high blood pressure. Dr. Gupta also points out a few other risk factors to discuss with your doctor before taking an NSAID:
- Diabetes (because it puts stress on the kidneys)
- Kidney disease or renal dysfunction
- Heart disease
- Gastrointestinal issues
Can’t tolerate NSAIDs? Try this alternative
If NSAIDs aren’t for you, consider swapping a pill for an ointment to tame pain and inflammation. “If you strained your knee or shoulder, for example, there are a lot of topical medications out there that are very powerful, like lidocaine, which you can apply right where you need it,” says Dr. Gupta, who encourages you to talk to your pharmacist about potential alternatives.
After all, the fewer drugs circulating through your system, the better. “Your body will thank you,” Dr. Gupta adds.
The bottom line on naproxen vs. ibuprofen
If you feel you need these medications for more than seven days a month, you’re not really treating the problem—you’re masking it, cautions Dr. Gupta, explaining that muting the pain signals your body sends may lead to bigger health problems down the road.
This is especially true for women, as we all-too-often try to “self-treat,” she adds. “If you’re in pain, have a conversation with your doctor to determine whether it’s safe to use these medications for more than a week,” she urges. “Physicians, pharmacists and healthcare professionals can help you learn what’s causing that pain signal if you spend some time with them and let them know what’s going on.”
Conversation
All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Woman's World does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.
