Antiperspirant vs. Deodorant: Which Is Best for Menopausal Sweat and Body Odor?
An ob-gyn settles the debate, plus shares a trick that makes antiperspirant more effective
Key Takeaways
- Hormonal changes during menopause can affect sweating, skin secretions and body odor.
- Antiperspirants reduce sweat, while deodorants help minimize or mask unpleasant body odor.
- Applying antiperspirant at night to completely dry skin can help improve its effectiveness.
During and after menopause, hot flashes can be accompanied by drenching sweats. But even when you aren’t in the throes of a hot flash or a night sweat, you may notice a change in how much you’re sweating or how you smell after activity. And when it comes to the debate of antiperspirant vs. deodorant, you may be wondering which one—or which combo—is your best bet in this stage of life.
“Many women notice changes in how much they sweat during perimenopause and menopause, although the experience can vary from person to person,” says Fahimeh Sasan, MD, an ob-gyn, founding physician at Kindbody, and Cure Hydration medical advisory board member. “Some women also notice that their natural body odor changes, even when their hygiene habits haven’t changed.”
Read on to discover why these changes occur, plus whether an antiperspirant, deodorant or combination product is best to help stop sweat and odor during menopause.
Why do sweating and body odor change after menopause?
There are a number of factors at play. The first, as is the case with many changes that happen during the change, is your hormones. “As estrogen levels change, the body’s thermostat can become more sensitive to even small changes in temperature,” explains Dr. Sasan. “This can trigger hot flashes and night sweats, sometimes causing women to sweat much more than they previously did.” Stress, anxiety, warm environments, spicy foods, alcohol and certain medications can also contribute to sweating, Dr. Sasan adds, as can changes in your metabolism and chronic issues such as thyroid conditions.
Changes in body odor often accompany an increase in your sweat level. “Increased sweating from hot flashes and night sweats can create more opportunity for odor-producing bacteria on the skin to break down sweat,” says Dr. Sasan. “And hormonal changes, particularly declining estrogen, may influence skin secretions and the balance of bacteria on the skin.”
Two key points to keep in mind: Not every post-menopausal woman sweats more, especially once vasomotor symptoms have declined. “Overall sweat production may decline with age,” Dr. Sasan says. And second, sweating more does not equal a more pungent body odor. “Sweat itself is generally odorless,” says Dr. Sasan. “Body odor develops when bacteria on the skin interact with sweat and other skin secretions.”
Antiperspirant vs. deodorant: Which is best during menopause?
If the product you’ve used to stay fresh for years suddenly feels like it’s not working anymore, don’t panic. This is quite common.
“If you’re sweating more frequently or experiencing more intense hot flashes and night sweats, the product you’ve relied on for years may not feel as effective as it once did. Changes in sweat production, skin chemistry and odor-producing bacteria can also affect how well a product works,” Dr. Sasan explains. “It doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve developed a tolerance to your deodorant. Rather, your body’s needs may have changed, and it may be time to reconsider the type of product you’re using.”
When to use antiperspirant
If sweating is your main concern, Dr. Sasan recommends an aluminum-based antiperspirant to temporarily block sweat glands. “[These ingredients] temporarily reduce the amount of sweat reaching the skin,” she explains. Antiperspirants work best when applied at night to completely dry skin, as opposed to only in the morning. One to try: Sweat Block Max Clinical Antiperspirant Roll-On.
When to use deodorant
If odor is the primary issue you’re experiencing, especially if your hot flashes have petered off and you find yourself sweating less, a deodorant to help combat odor-causing bacteria may be sufficient. “Deodorants help minimize or mask odor but don’t prevent sweating,” Dr. Sasan says. One option: Lume Solid Stick Whole Body Deodorant.
When to use both antiperspirant and deodorant
Finally, if you’ve noticed an increase in both sweating and body odor, a combination deodorant and antiperspirant is a smart place to start and help you feel confident all day. “If regular products aren’t providing enough relief, a clinical-strength or prescription antiperspirant may be worth discussing with a dermatologist,” Dr. Sasan adds. One to try: Secret Clinical Sleep, Don’t Sweat It Antiperspirant/Deodorant.
The bottom line on antiperspirant vs. deodorant
Whether you’re dealing with increased sweating, odor or both, know that you don’t have to just suffer through it. Choosing the right antiperspirant, deodorant or combination product can help with odor protection and/or sweat production, keeping you feeling and smelling fresh all day. “Most importantly, don’t feel that you must simply accept these changes,” Dr. Sasan says. “There are effective ways to manage them!”
Conversation
All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Woman's World does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.