Ann Patchett, 62, Shuts Down No. 1 ‘Whistler’ Fan Theory: ‘You’re Wrong’

One of the buzziest book conversations this fall has been about a wild fan theory for Ann Patchett’s latest bestselling novel Whistler. Woman’s World had the opportunity to hear Patchett’s live reaction to the theory. Check out her response here. And take heed, this story contains spoilers.

What is the ‘Whistler’ fan theory everyone’s talking about?

If you’ve read Whistler (or if it is on your TBR pile) you know that it centers around Daphne and an unexpected reunion with her former stepfather Eddie. The two hadn’t seen each other since they were in a harrowing winter car crash four decades earlier.

Here’s where the fun fan theory comes into play. The theory initially surfaced back in August at the First Draft Book Club in Phoenix, run by Barbara VanDenburgh. A fan proposed: What if Eddie died in that long-go accident and he is only returning now to Daphne’s life as a ghost? VanDenburgh shared in her newsletter: “The room erupted. I mean, erupted. People were screaming (in a good way, but still, screaming)… We seriously almost started a fistfight in the parking lot.” And that theory has been dividing readers ever since.

Ann Patchett’s response will make you laugh out loud

Then last week Patchett was at a live event in New York City, at Temple Emanu-El. There, she was being interviewed by award-winning podcaster and book influencer Zibby Owens for a sold out conversation, part of the Women on the Move series.

During the Q&A, someone from the audience asked Patchett directly about the fan theory swirling around Whistler. And Patchett, always one to call a spade a spade, answered, “I am somebody who’s like ‘free to be you and me, your interpretation is completely valid.’ NO! No.” The crowd burst into laughter. There’s a reason we all love Patchett for her brilliant, brutal honesty. Then Patchett continued, “There was that Bruce Willis movie, The Sixth Sense, where it turns out he’s dead the whole time. No. I appreciate you bringing your vision to the table, but you’re wrong.”

Why Patchett finally had to address this theory

Patchett is no stranger to people applying their own unique interpretations to her stories. It comes with the territory of being a creator. At a National Writers Series (NWS) event in Michigan in June, where Woman’s World was present, Patchett shared her generous, relaxed philosophy of releasing art into the world for people to make of it what they will. “This is the answer, which is at some point you let go. At some point, you stop worrying or trying to control what anybody thinks.”

However, this fan theory about Eddie’s early death was one she needed to address publicly. Why? Perhaps because the character Eddie in the book was modeled after Patchett’s real-life dear friend Jim Fox, who lived a long life before dying of cancer at the age of 85.

Is ‘Whistler’ based on Ann Patchett’s real life? She explains

This isn’t the first time Patchett has shut down speculation about Whistler, either. The book has been called Patchett’s most autobiographical novel to date, a label she rejects, in part. Yes, it is a story of multiple stepfathers, something Patchett experienced in her own life. But on the NWS stage while on book tour, she was quick to draw a line between real life and fiction.

Deal of the Day

This Deep Conditioning Collagen Hair Mask for Has 4.9 Stars and Is 80% Off — Get It for $20! View Deal

Patchett shared this anecdote: “I was on stage being interviewed last week by a wonderful novelist who is a friend of mine, and she said, ‘Well, clearly this is about your relationship with your stepfather, Mike.’ And I was like, ‘Are you kidding me? This couldn’t possibly be. I mean, my mother was married to Mike for 25 years, and he was crazy. There’s no way this is Mike!’”

But the interviewer doubled down on her interpretation, saying she was “positive” that was what the book was about. And Patchett told the audience, “She never met Mike anyway. This is what happens.” Yes, people read these wonderful stories and try to find meaning in them—in all forms. And sometimes it’s a surprise for the author on the receiving end to hear.

Bottom line: Keep reading great books like the ones Patchett writes and recommends and keep trying to find meaning in them. Your fan theories might be right, they might be wrong, but they are always worthy of deep thinking. Plus, fun fan theories have a way of building exciting and community with other readers. As VanDenburgh shared on social media after this particular Whistler theory gained legs: “Don’t let them tell you books are dead.”