When Can an Employer be Held Liable for Workplace Sexual Harassment?
Sexual harassment in the workplace is a serious concern. Employers have a responsibility to keep workers safe, but there are limits to their liability. Understanding what is required of employers can help keep workers safer and provide survivors context to pursue legal remedies.
Workplace sexual harassment is a serious issue that employers cannot afford to take lightly. Not only do survivors of sexual harassment often suffer from physical injuries and long-term emotional distress, but the company itself may suffer consequences as well. A company may be held liable for sexual harassment that happens on its property, at company-sanctioned events or involving its employees.
An employer is not automatically liable for any harassment that occurs at work. But a business can face liability when negligence, failure to respond to known risks or certain conduct contributes to harm. Whether the company bears any responsibility for workplace sexual harassment comes down to a combination of factors, including the relationship between the employer and the alleged perpetrator and the laws governing the claim. Comprehensive legal guidance from a firm like Arias Sanguinetti Wang & Team, LLP can help survivors and employers protect their rights.
Employer liability for workplace sexual harassment
Employers have a legal responsibility to provide a safe environment for their employees and comply with applicable state, local and federal safety and employment laws. Part of those regulations means employers must take steps to prevent sexual harassment, respond appropriately to complaints and take reasonable steps to mitigate foreseeable risks.
“Too often, institutions entrusted with the livelihoods of others abuse their power. ” says Mike Arias, founding and managing partner at Arias Sanguinetti Wang & Team, LLP. “These cases expose injustices that have been ignored, disregarded or hidden.”
The fact that harassment occurred at a workplace does not, by itself, establish employer liability. A company’s responsibility depends on the legal basis for the claim and evidence connecting the organization to the harassment.
For example, if management received complaints about an employee’s sexually aggressive behavior but failed to investigate or take appropriate corrective action, the company could possibly be held liable. A company could also face liability if it failed to address a known security risk or allowed a supervisor to sexually exploit an employee.
But there are instances in which a company may not be held liable for workplace sexual harassment. If a perpetrator’s actions were not reasonably foreseeable by the company, or if the perpetrator was not directly connected to the company, the employee might not have a claim against the company. Whether a company can be held liable in these cases would depend on a wider array of evidence and legal precedent.
Direct negligence versus vicarious liability
There are two legal definitions that can help to explain when an employer may be held responsible for workplace harassment.
Direct negligence focuses on an employer’s actions or failures. If an organization failed to take reasonable precautions, ignored credible warnings, inadequately supervised employees or failed to respond appropriately after learning about a risk, that can show direct negligence.
For example, if multiple employees report sexually aggressive behavior by a supervisor, and management dismisses those complaints and retains the supervisor in a position to continue that unwanted behavior, the company could be held liable for direct negligence.
Vicarious liability focuses on whether an employer can be held legally responsible for conduct committed by someone in a role that makes the organization responsible under the law.
For example, federal employment law applies special rules to harassment by supervisors. An employer may be held responsible if a supervisor’s harassment results in a tangible employment action like termination, demotion or a significant change in employment status. When a supervisor’s harassment creates a hostile work environment without a tangible employment action, the employer may have a defense if it took reasonable steps to prevent and correct harassment and the employee failed to use available preventive or corrective opportunities.
What an employer knows matters
An employer’s knowledge of sexual harassment or misconduct is critical when determining liability. Here are some terms to know:
- Actual notice means the employer knew about the problem. That knowledge could come from a formal complaint, a report to human resources, a manager’s direct observation or a communication describing threatening or inappropriate behavior.
- Constructive notice refers to circumstances where an employer should have known about a problem, even if no one formally reported it. Repeated incidents of harassment, visible warning signs of inappropriate behavior or information available to managers may be taken into account to determine if an employer had constructive notice. For example, an employer will have an uphill battle arguing that misconduct was unforeseeable if several employees independently raised concerns about the same person.
Employees should know that they do not have to report misconduct through any one particular channel for their concerns to matter. Information given to a supervisor, HR or another responsible manager may be relevant, although the legal significance of each report depends on many factors.
Workplace policies and preventive measures
Written policies alone do not guarantee a safe workplace. Policies are only as effective as they are understood and enforced.
Employers can reduce risks to employees as well as provide protection for themselves by establishing clear reporting procedures, providing appropriate training, supervising employees effectively and maintaining security measures. Reporting systems should always give employees alternatives when the person accused of misconduct is their direct supervisor or someone with influence over their employment.
When a complaint is filed, employers should conduct a prompt, thorough and impartial investigation. Interim safety measures may be necessary to reduce contact between the parties and prevent further harm during the investigation. Those measures should not unfairly penalize the employee who reported the misconduct.
An organization’s response is critical. A documented, reasonable response can help demonstrate that the employer took its obligations seriously. Ignoring complaints, discouraging reports or failing to address a known risk may create additional legal exposure.
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission provides guidance on workplace harassment and employer responsibilities.
Evidence that an employer might be liable
Relevant information that can establish potential liability of an employer includes:
- Previous complaints: Reports of harassment, threats, unwanted touching, inappropriate comments or similar conduct involving the alleged perpetrator
- Workplace communications: Emails, text messages, internal chats and other records can show what employees and managers knew.
- Personnel and supervision records: Information about prior disciplinary actions or relevant employment decisions
- Witness statements: Accounts from people who witnessed the incident, heard disclosures or observed warning signs
- Incident reports and investigation records: Documents showing how the employer responded to the complaints and if it followed its own procedures
- Records of employment changes: Schedules, performance reviews, transfer decisions and other documentation may help establish whether an employee experienced retaliation after reporting misconduct.
Employee Protections Against Retaliation
Reporting sexual misconduct at work can be scary for an employee who depends on their job for income, health insurance and career advancement. Federal and state laws protect employees who report sexual harassment or participate in investigations against retaliation.
Examples of retaliation can include firing, demotion, reduced hours, poor reassignments, threats and any actions that could discourage an employee from raising a concern. An employer does not necessarily have to fire someone for retaliation to become a legal issue.
Not every workplace disagreement or unfavorable decision constitutes unlawful retaliation. Employers are allowed to make legitimate employment decisions, but they cannot use those decisions to punish people who report harm.
Employees who believe they have been a victim of retaliation after filing a claim or participating in an investigation should document when they reported the misconduct, who received the report and what changed afterward.
Civil lawsuits and criminal proceedings are different
Workplace sexual harassment may lead to a criminal investigation, a civil lawsuit or both. These proceedings serve different purposes and apply different standards.
A criminal case is brought by the government to determine whether the accused committed a crime. Criminal proceedings generally require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction can result in imprisonment, fines, probation, inclusion on a sex offender registry and more.
A civil case is brought by the survivor and seeks damages for harm. In civil court, a survivor can pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost income, emotional distress or other recognized damages. Civil claims do not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. A civil claim may be brought against the alleged perpetrator as well as an employer in the case of workplace sexual harassment.
A criminal conviction is not necessary to pursue a civil claim. In cases where a prosecutor may not bring charges or a criminal case does not result in a conviction, evidence may still support a civil action.
How company liability can differ by perpetrator
The alleged perpetrator’s role within a company can affect the employer’s legal responsibilities.
Supervisors: When the accused is a supervisor, workplace authority to influence hiring, firing, promotion and employment decisions is particularly important. Federal harassment law applies special rules around an employer’s responsibility for supervisor misconduct.
Colleagues: When the accused is a coworker, the employer’s knowledge of the conduct and response to it are important for determining liability under federal harassment law and negligence claims under state law.
When the accused is a customer, contractor, volunteer or other nonemployee, whether the employer had control over the individual, knew or should have known about the harassment and whether the company failed to take fast and appropriate corrective action all come into play. The extent of the employer’s authority and the nature of the workplace relationship can matter.
Filing deadlines and legal options
Time limits can impact an employee’s ability to file a civil claim for workplace sexual harassment. Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, employees generally must file a charge with the EEOC before pursuing a federal employment discrimination lawsuit within 180 calendar days from the incident. This deadline is extended to 300 days in certain jurisdictions. Filing an internal workplace complaint does not pause the deadline for filing an EEOC charge.
Those deadlines are not universal. Federal employees may follow a different process, state laws may provide separate deadlines and personal injury or other civil claims may be subject to other limitation periods. The deadline may also depend on whether the claim concerns harassment, retaliation, negligence or another legal violation.
Understanding employer responsibility
Employers cannot prevent every harmful act at the workplace, but they can establish effective safeguards, respond appropriately to credible concerns and protect employees from unlawful retaliation. Understanding an employer’s legal responsibility can help survivors make informed decisions about their legal options and help organizations keep themselves and their employees safer.
The information provided in this article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as legal, financial, medical or professional advice. Readers should not rely solely on the content of this article and are encouraged to seek professional advice tailored to their specific circumstances. We disclaim any liability for any loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of, or reliance on, the information presented.